In a quest to uncover the greatest player of all time at each Premier League club, Mail Sport, along with its readers, is embarking on an exciting journey. Today, we shine the spotlight on Newcastle United, a club steeped in history and rich in talent.

From the pioneering days of William McCracken to the goal-scoring exploits of Alan Shearer, the Magpies have been blessed with some incredible players. Now, it’s your turn to decide who stands out as the best of the best.

Newcastle United’s trophy cabinet may not be overflowing, but the club has produced some remarkable individuals who have left an indelible mark on the beautiful game. The challenge lies in separating the legends from the mere mortals.

Bill McCracken, the founder of the offside trap, was a dominant force in the early 20th century, winning three league titles and an FA Cup during his 19-year stint at St James’ Park. His innovative tactics and leadership qualities set the tone for future generations of Newcastle players.

“Wor” Jackie Milburn has a stand named after him at St James’ Park and is a fan icon at Newcastle

Hughie Gallacher, a diminutive yet prolific striker, was the first of the great Scottish entertainers to don the black-and-white jersey. His 36 goals in the 1926-27 season still stand as a club record, and his legacy paved the way for future Magpies legends.

Jackie Milburn, affectionately known as “Wor Jackie,” was a lightning-quick forward who terrorized defenses in the 1950s. His incredible speed and finishing ability earned him a place in the hearts of Newcastle fans, and his iconic status is still celebrated today.

Only 5ft 5ins tall, Hughie Gallacher didn’t lack in self-belief and he scored 36 goals in the championship season

Bobby Moncur, the last Newcastle captain to lift a trophy, was a commanding presence at the back, and his goalscoring exploits in the 1969 Fairs Cup final will forever be etched in the memories of the Toon Army.

Malcom Macdonald, a cocky Londoner with a penchant for the spectacular, was the first player to score five goals in a game for England. His clinical finishing and swaggering style made him a hero on Tyneside.