England are just two wins away from European glory after a nail-biting penalty shootout victory over Switzerland in the quarterfinals. However, with the team yet to find its rhythm, manager Gareth Southgate still has some tough decisions to make ahead of the semifinal clash against the Netherlands.
With just two games to go, Southgate is still searching for his ideal starting eleven and the perfect tactical setup. The switch to a back three in the quarterfinal showed some promise, but was it enough to convince Southgate to stick with it? And what about Harry Kane, who has struggled to find his best form? Should Southgate persist with his captain, or is it time to make a bold change?
Six Mail Sport experts have shared their preferred lineups for the semifinal showdown with the Dutch. While there is some consensus on a few positions, opinions vary greatly on others, reflecting the difficult choices facing Southgate.
For Chris Sutton, two changes are in order. He would bring in Luke Shaw and Marc Guehi for Kieran Trippier and Ezri Konsa, keeping the same 3-4-3 formation that Southgate employed against Switzerland. Sutton believes this lineup gives England the best chance to advance to the final.
Chris Sutton’s Starting XI: Ramsdale; James, Stones, Guehi, Shaw, Rice, Bellingham; Mount, Sterling, Saka; Kane
Oliver Holt’s Starting XI
Oliver Holt would also bring in Shaw and Guehi, but he goes a step further by suggesting Southgate drop Kane in favor of Ivan Toney. While acknowledging that this would be a bold move, Holt points out that Kane appears to be far from his best form and that Toney has been impressive off the bench.
Oliver Holt’s Starting XI: Ramsdale; James, Stones, Guehi, Shaw, Rice, Bellingham; Mount, Sterling, Saka; Toney
Ian Ladyman’s Starting XI
Ian Ladyman agrees with sticking to the 3-4-3 formation, but he would make just one change to the starting eleven. He suggests giving Cole Palmer a chance in place of Phil Foden, who has failed to find his best form in the tournament so far. Ladyman keeps faith in Kane, believing he is the best center forward in Europe despite his underwhelming performances.
Ian Ladyman’s Starting XI: Ramsdale; James, Stones, Guehi, Trippier, Rice, Bellingham; Mount, Palmer, Saka; Kane
Craig Hope’s Starting XI
Craig Hope takes a different approach, switching back to a 4-3-3 formation. He would drop Foden for Anthony Gordon, who has been waiting patiently for his chance. Hope also advocates for the controversial decision to bench Kane, arguing that his lack of form is hurting the team. Hope believes Toney deserves a start after his impressive substitute appearances.
Craig Hope’s Starting XI: Ramsdale; Alexander-Arnold, Stones, Guehi, Shaw; Rice, Bellingham, Mount; Saka, Toney, Sterling
Mike Keegan’s Starting XI
Mike Keegan also opts for a back four, but his lineup has a different look. He would give Trent Alexander-Arnold the nod over Kyle Walker at right-back, citing his superior attacking threat. Keegan would also bench Foden in favor of Palmer, but he keeps faith in Kane to lead the line.
Mike Keegan’s Starting XI: Ramsdale; Alexander-Arnold, Stones, Guehi, Shaw; Rice, Bellingham, Mount; Saka, Kane, Sterling
Sami Mokbel’s Starting XI
Sami Mokbel is the only expert who would keep the back three intact, with Guehi and Shaw coming in for Konsa and Trippier. He believes there were enough positive signs in the quarterfinal to persist with this formation. Mokbel keeps faith in Kane, who retains his place in the lineup.
Sami Mokbel’s Starting XI: Ramsdale; James, Stones, Guehi, Shaw, Trippier; Rice, Bellingham; Mount, Sterling, Saka; Kane